The teenage activists, sporting shirts with a “no guns” logo and bearing the message “Piece Out,” accompanied the winning filmmakers behind a documentary about the 2012 Sandy Hook Elementary School tragedy.
The Peabody Awards ended up being tragically timely, with organization’s annual celebration of winners falling a day after a high-school shooting in Santa Fe, Texas left 10 people dead, the deadliest such attack since the school shooting in Parkland, Florida, after which a number of the teenage survivors have become activists for efforts to improve safety for students.
One of the 30 winners across TV, radio/podcasts and the web was the documentary Newtown, about the aftermath of the 2012 Sandy Hook Elementary School shooting in Connecticut.
Newtown director Kim A. Snyder has, in recent months, been embedded with the Parkland students and their community working on another documentary chronicling what’s transpired after that tragedy.
“It’ll be a very different kind of film than Newtown, I think,” Snyder told The Hollywood Reporter ahead of the awards show. “Whereas I think Newtown seized on a moment, a shameful mark in American history that should have changed everything, this is all about the youth movement and about anger and fury and change, about capturing the spirit of these young people as they navigate trauma and as they make change. And we’re all certain this may be a different moment for the country.”
And she was accompanied on Saturday night with by survivors from Parkland as well as the parents and sister of Newtown victim Daniel Barden. After walking the carpet with their team and the activists, many of whom were wearing black T-shirts with a “no guns” logo and the phrase “Piece Out,” Snyder and producer Maria Cuomo Cole delivered a heartfelt message about the ongoing relevance of their film.
“It’s unfathomable that we stand here tonight after yet another 10 slain yesterday at a high school in Santa Fe, Texas,” Snyder said. “We dedicate this award to all victims of gun violence and with renewed hope, we stand united with the youth movement in their ongoing efforts to create the demand and the change that they deserve.”
Cuomo Cole added, “It takes courage to give voice to the most unimaginable devastation and one of the most shameful marks in American history. One that should have changed and could have changed — could have saved lives. But no more would haves and should haves because now we have what it’s going to take. We have young leadership; these brave activists from around the country, from Parkland and Newtown, we are so grateful to you and we’re with you all the way.”
Then Daniel Barden’s sister took the stage and urged the well-heeled guests at New York’s Cipriani Wall Street — including Carol Burnett, John Oliver, CBS News’ Bob Schieffer and Jeff Fager and the people behind TV shows like Insecure, Marvelous Mrs. Maisel, The Handmaid’s Tale and Saturday Night Live — to take action.
Declaring she stands with the students from Parkland, Santa Fe and “victims of gun violence everywhere,” Natalie Bardem said, “I am asking every single person in this room to get up and do something — we need you. On behalf of my little brother, and children everywhere, I beg you, help us.”
It was a moving speech that prompted the audience to give the elder Barden, a high-school sophomore, a standing ovation.
Entertainment winners Insecure and Marvelous Mrs. Maisel, which were honored shortly after Newtown, quickly livened things up.
Accepting for Insecure, star Issa Rae took a moment to point out that it was a rare win for her show.
“We don’t win anything, so this is huge. Nobody’s counting the number of times we’ve been nominated. What is it 19? But we’re not, so thank you for winning an award that represents storytelling for the culture,” she said. “It’s just a huge honor for us.”
Earlier on the red carpet, co-star Yvonne Orji told THR that the award was specially meaningful because, “We were honored for not only the work we’re doing but the message behind the work we’re doing.” “It feels very prestigious,” she added. “It feels very regal, if you will. I know today’s Meghan Markle’s day, and I feel like today’s our day, too.”
The show was honored after its second season, which Orji conceded felt freer than the show’s first season.
“I think we’ve been really proud of all of our seasons to be honest but like season one had to lay the foundation like who we are, who are these characters and then by season two, you got to know them, you got to love them, you got to be annoyed by them, and then we were just able to grow as a cast with the stories that we wanted to tell. We were never boxed in.”
Maisel creator Amy Sherman-Palladino, meanwhile, offered a bleakly comic take on the current state of the world.
“I do believe the world is completely ending; we’re completely fucked. There’s absolutely nothing we can do, but every morning that you wake up and PBS is still around, there’s a little bit of hope,” she said in her acceptance speech, referencing the network behind multiple Peabody winners.
Speaking of bleak comedy, host Hasan Minhaj joked that fellow entertainment winner, The Handmaid’s Tale, is, to Vice President Pence, “the breakout comedy of the year.”
Accepting for the series, showrunner Bruce Miller also acknowledged the other honorees, saying, “I feel a little out of my element here because Handmaid’s is fiction and we’re surrounded by journalists and storytellers and documentarians who tell true stories about the real world. Please don’t stop. Keep working to make sure that Handmaid’s Tale stays fictional. You’re doing God’s work.”
Earlier on the red carpet, Miller said that he wished his show wasn’t so eerily relevant.
“I would really hope for the show to be untimely as soon as possible. It would be really nice if it was completely irrelevant. I see things all the time [in the news], and it’s scary. Sometimes we shot exactly that scene,” he told THR. “We’re reacting to the same winds of change that are affecting everybody, so it’s not like we have a Magic 8 ball. We’re just making the same guesses that other people are making and unfortunately those things are coming true.”
The show ended with Carol Burnett accepting the organization’s first ever career achievement award, given to her by Maisel star Rachel Brosnahan, who hoped that she would actually meet Burnett after her out-of-body experience accepting a Golden Globe from the veteran comedian.
Recalling that experience, Brosnahan told the Peabody audience, “All I can remember is walking up to the stage and kind of like pointing at her and making some mouth sounds that were vaguely incoherent and then I promptly blacked the fuck out. And after what may or may not have been a speech, I proceeded to exit the stage the wrong way and totally missed our photo op, so I’m hoping that take two goes better than take one tonight and that we get to hand trophies back and forth to each other for the rest of all time.”
Burnett, before she delivered her trademark Tarzan yell and ear tug, praised Brosnahan, and the two got their picture, below.